viernes, 3 de abril de 2009

Thoughts on: Gaining Clarity on Our Goals

The main objective for teachers is to make students learn, however, there are many goals involved in that process. Since in the first chapter of Understanding by Design its authors, Wiggins and Mc Tighe, invited us to reflect and deal with issues such as understanding and knowledge, now, chapter 3 “Gaining Clarity on our Goals”, invites us, as future teachers, to respond to Essential Questions in order to plan the learning process and make it more meaningful with fundamental elements such as Established Goals, Understandings, Knowledge and Skills. It is extremely necessary for any teacher to set the main objectives and communicate the students what they are going to learn. This is the only way to avoid, as the authors state, the twin sins: aimless coverage of content and isolated activities which may be hardly engaged with the goals that learners have in mind.

One of the main points is that students have to be active participants in their own learning process and how it will be. Since they are not the ones who plan this, teachers have to be aware that the five components are the key for their cognitive development. Teachers as well as students should be aware of the importance of them and how they are going to be carried out, so that the learning outcomes can be fulfilled by the end of the period. Learning outcomes are part of what is called long term objectives, which let the teachers to have a perpective or an overview of how this process is going to finish in terms of expected results, but at the same time (within these), many short term aims may exist, so we can have all together. This is where the Essential Questions take place. These are not expected to be answered, but the idea of them is to develop in students skills like: discussion, reflection, problem solving, research and debate.
For instance, if a teacher is teaching 8th graders about food, will it be meaningful for them to learn about isolated vocabulary items? The answer is maybe, but only for the time they are acquiring those, however, they would be really menaingful for them by the time they are able to discuss about a healthy life, and illnesses such as overweightness and anorexia. Therefore, if students are able to apply those concepts in a discussion, then we are talking about Understanding. As the authours point out: “Understandings are the constructivist results of attemps by the student to make senseof the work and lessons, using inquiri, performance and reflection” (Wiggins and Mc Tighe)

In order to continue with the idea of involving students in the way their study plan should be like, I will bring the point of Unpacking standards, which means to analyse in detail and make it easier for learners to understand it, so that they can get the “big ideas and core tasks contained within”(Wiggins and Mc Tighe). For all students, these standarts are usually a confusing, complex and abstract idea. If this whole abjective was separated into more clear and down-to-earth passages for students, in order to make the aims closer to their everyday life, it would be easier and more motivating for them because they are going to have claer in mind what they are going to learn. So, from them an on, verbs such as; compare, name, analyse, interpret, identify, etc; will start appearing, which mey represent different objectives. This is what Unpacking standards mean, so they are able to find the big ides and the core tasks. Another reason why Unpacking standard is so useful, is that since teachers are always running out of time to get all the set objectives done, this would let them to determine which ones deserve more to be taught than others, which are more important than others, that will certainly mean meaningful learning. As the authors say: “Teachers can never cover all of the facts and skills on a given topic, given time restrictions and content overload. However, they can focus on a smaller set of big ideas and core tasks in the discipline by framing work around essential questions and appropriate performance assessment”(Wiggins and Mc Tighe).

To finish, I insist on the idea to make students acquire their study plan from the beginning, by all means. They know better than us (as teachers) what they want to be taught and in what way. Teachers are not authorities anymore. There should be communication and dialogue between both parts. What it is important, is that the teacher must have the class objectives as well as the expected outcomes are well set, and are based on the learner’s reality.

8 comentarios:

  1. I really agree with you Cristina and also with Wiggins in the fact that students must be part of their own learning process. They must feel active and not only being the teacher as the main character of the class. Sadly, most of the teachers think that they are the only one that can give their opinions and that they have the last word for everything. I hope we can change this old fashioned idea!!!

    ResponderEliminar
  2. I totally agree that students have to have the role of participants in the learning process. I really think that teachers should promote the student center learning and let them apply what they learn in the class.

    ResponderEliminar
  3. With your example of make students be critical thinkers, it comes to my mind what we have been listening since first year. I think it is so important to teach in context, where students can
    learn by discovering and reflecting the new knowledge by themselves with the teacher's help. Good example!

    ResponderEliminar
  4. To appeal the essential question is a great advantage for students. It help them to increase or to develop their critical thinking. even more, it make them to be more independ in their own learning process. however, it is necessary that all this process goes closely guided by the teacher. thus, the students feel more confident and willing to achieve whatever they want.

    ResponderEliminar
  5. Long term objectives are absolutely necessary in your plan. When teachers plan they need to be focused on what they are expecting, or expected outcomes, because the idea is to prepare something with a good support and a reasonable period of time to make the process consistant.

    ResponderEliminar
  6. I think you were good at explaining the unpacking part and why it is really important. This process of taking students to the core of the ideas and give them the necessary tools to dig up themselves is such a useful strategy. Teachers should do it in order to connect it with the essential ideas and develop the cognitive skills you mentioned.

    ResponderEliminar
  7. As we can find in this comment, Learning outcomes are part of what is called long term objectives, which is the result of a complete process where every single part of the learning and assessment process is put in practice by teachers and students.

    ResponderEliminar
  8. Has comunicado bien el desafío de los estandares, y me encantó tu descripción de "desempacar" los estandares. Esto de "cubrir" la materia definitivamente es un reto para profesores mundiales, pero también tenemos el desafío de asegurar que los estudiantes verdaderamente agarrar las ideas principales de ellos. No es un deber fácil.

    ResponderEliminar